World: r3wp
[Rebol School] Rebol School
older newer | first last |
Vladimir 30-Oct-2008 [712] | I noticed UDP disabled in my router configuration... could it have something to do with my problem? |
Graham 30-Oct-2008 [713] | can you try this ? system/schemes/ftp/passive: true |
Vladimir 30-Oct-2008 [714] | It does not help..... :( As I wrote before... It worked without problem for half a year.... now I have new provider... if I connect my pc directly to WAN it works.... When I connect PC to my router lan port it does not.... Everything else works.... HTTP , FTP from Total commander... upload download...., torrents work.... |
Pekr 30-Oct-2008 [715x2] | Vladimir - what is your FTP user name? Does it contain @ char? If so, you need small patch. Look at how is Total commander FTP configured. It should work. Aren't you using proxy? You might install WireShark and watch packets, that is the very low level of networking, you will see everything there. Then you could compare your Total Commander connection with your REBOL one and see, where they differ.... |
also - what are your directories? Simple ones? Without space? Or is there space in it? | |
Vladimir 30-Oct-2008 [717] | user name is "visaprom.com" Total commander is set up simply... use passive is ON... here is what is happening with ftp/passive: true: Net-log: "215 UNIX Type: L8" Net-log: ["PWD" "25"] Net-log: {257 "/" is your current location} Net-log: ["PASV" "227"] Net-log: "227 Entering Passive Mode (194,9,94,127,235,183)" Net-log: [["CWD" port/path] ["25" "200"]] this is where it pauses and then: Net-log: "Closing cmd port 3565 21" ** Access Error: Network timeout ** Where: confirm ** Near: to-port: open/binary/new/direct server/:file |
Pekr 30-Oct-2008 [718x2] | so username contains .com? Not sure it is allowed or that url parser handless it correctly, but I might be wrong ... |
do you have any other account to try? | |
Anton 30-Oct-2008 [720] | He got passed the login stage - that's not the problem. |
Vladimir 30-Oct-2008 [721] | just a sec... |
Pekr 30-Oct-2008 [722] | ok, so port/path? What is the path you are trying to access? |
Anton 30-Oct-2008 [723] | FTP runs over TCP, not UDP. |
Vladimir 30-Oct-2008 [724] | as I said... it works from other connections.... only problem is this new one in this office.... it has to be something with router.... Im looking configuration pages for two days now... :( |
Anton 30-Oct-2008 [725] | Does the FTP server identify itself anywhere in the log ? |
Pekr 30-Oct-2008 [726] | So the same script works from other locations, right? Hmm, that is really weird ... |
Vladimir 30-Oct-2008 [727x2] | here is script result... |
to-port: open/binary/new/direct server/:file URL Parse: visaprom.com password ftp.visaprom.com none apl/ ik104.zip Net-log: ["Opening" "tcp" "for" "FTP"] Net-log: [none ["220" "230"]] Net-log: {220---------- Welcome to Pure-FTPd [privsep] [TLS] ----------} Net-log: "220-You are user number 188 of 400 allowed." Net-log: "220-Local time is now 11:33. Server port: 21." Net-log: "220-This is a private system - No anonymous login" Net-log: {220-IPv6 connections are also welcome on this server.} Net-log: {220 You will be disconnected after 15 minutes of inactivity.} Net-log: [["USER" port/user] "331"] Net-log: "331 User visaprom.com OK. Password required" Net-log: [["PASS" port/pass] "230"] Net-log: {230-User visaprom.com has group access to: www } Net-log: "230 OK. Current restricted directory is /" Net-log: ["SYST" "*"] Net-log: "215 UNIX Type: L8" Net-log: ["PWD" "25"] Net-log: {257 "/" is your current location} Net-log: ["PASV" "227"] Net-log: "227 Entering Passive Mode (194,9,94,127,216,138)" Net-log: [["CWD" port/path] ["25" "200"]] | |
Pekr 30-Oct-2008 [729] | Vladimir - IIRC, FTP is strange beast, and network admins don't like it. FTP uses port 21 to establish connection, but to transfer data, other port is used - 20 IIRC. |
Vladimir 30-Oct-2008 [730x4] | path is simply one directory name.... |
thats what is bugging me.... ftp from windows command line works... | |
from commander works... | |
even my script works up to the point.... | |
Pekr 30-Oct-2008 [734] | You also should be sure, that you use passive mode. So check your firewall, if port 20 is opened. But usually all ports going to WAN are opened ... |
Vladimir 30-Oct-2008 [735x4] | [["CWD" port/path] ["25" "200"]] |
what does it mean? | |
port 25? | |
Ill try to open port 25 ? | |
Pekr 30-Oct-2008 [739] | here's list from my system: connecting to: www.jablunkovsko.cz Net-log: [none ["220" "230"]] Net-log: "220 (vsFTPd 1.2.1)" Net-log: [["USER" port/user] "331"] Net-log: "331 Please specify the password." Net-log: [["PASS" port/pass] "230"] Net-log: "230 Login successful." Net-log: ["SYST" "*"] Net-log: "215 UNIX Type: L8" Net-log: ["PWD" "25"] Net-log: {257 "/"} Net-log: "Opening listen port 50061" Net-log: [["PORT" port/locals/active-check] "200"] Net-log: "200 PORT command successful. Consider using PASV." Net-log: "Type: dir" Net-log: ["TYPE A" "200"] Net-log: "200 Switching to ASCII mode." Net-log: ["LIST" ["150" "125"]] Net-log: "150 Here comes the directory listing." Net-log: "Closing listen port 50061" Net-log: "Closing data port 193.85.151.2 50061 20" Net-log: [none ["226" "250"]] Net-log: "226 Directory send OK." Net-log: "Caching cmd-port www.jablunkovsko.cz 50060 21" |
Anton 30-Oct-2008 [740x2] | Check here to understand FTP return codes: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ftp#FTP_return_codes |
2xx: Positive Completion reply so you can see the 200 codes when things went well. | |
Pekr 30-Oct-2008 [742] | Vladimir: does simple one liner as print read ftp://user:[pass-:-ftp-:-domain-:-com] fails too? |
Vladimir 30-Oct-2008 [743x2] | Ill try... in a minute |
hey guys thanks for helping ! :) | |
Anton 30-Oct-2008 [745] | Well, it looks like the PureFTPd server likes passive mode less than it likes active mode. |
Graham 30-Oct-2008 [746] | [["CWD" port/path] ["25" "200"]] doesn't that mean, match the next response against 25* |
Vladimir 30-Oct-2008 [747x2] | print read ftp://visaprom.com:[pass-:-ftp-:-visaprom-:-com] URL Parse: visaprom.com 8ofhjo99 ftp.visaprom.com none none none Net-log: ["Opening" "tcp" "for" "FTP"] Net-log: [none ["220" "230"]] Net-log: {220---------- Welcome to Pure-FTPd [privsep] [TLS] ----------} Net-log: "220-You are user number 210 of 400 allowed." Net-log: "220-Local time is now 11:43. Server port: 21." Net-log: "220-This is a private system - No anonymous login" Net-log: {220-IPv6 connections are also welcome on this server.} Net-log: {220 You will be disconnected after 15 minutes of inactivity.} Net-log: [["USER" port/user] "331"] Net-log: "331 User visaprom.com OK. Password required" Net-log: [["PASS" port/pass] "230"] Net-log: {230-User visaprom.com has group access to: www } Net-log: "230 OK. Current restricted directory is /" Net-log: ["SYST" "*"] Net-log: "215 UNIX Type: L8" Net-log: ["PWD" "25"] Net-log: {257 "/" is your current location} Net-log: ["PASV" "227"] Net-log: "227 Entering Passive Mode (194,9,94,127,232,3)" Net-log: "Type: dir" Net-log: ["TYPE A" "200"] Net-log: "Closing cmd port 3783 21" ** Access Error: Network timeout ** Where: confirm ** Near: print read ftp://visaprom.com:[8ofhjo99-:-ftp-:-visaprom-:-com] |
here is what simple print read ftp does... :) | |
Pekr 30-Oct-2008 [749] | ouch, password leaked here ;-) |
Graham 30-Oct-2008 [750] | the server is closing the port .. |
Pekr 30-Oct-2008 [751] | I tried it here, here's where it starts to differ: Net-log: ["TYPE A" "200"] Net-log: "200 TYPE is now ASCII" Net-log: ["LIST" ["150" "125"]] Net-log: "150 Accepted data connection" Net-log: "Closing data port 194.9.94.127 50078 56405" Net-log: [none ["226" "250"]] Net-log: "226-Options: -a -l " Net-log: "226 11 matches total" Net-log: "Caching cmd-port 194.9.94.127 50077 21" apl/ apl101/ apl104/ apl105/ apl201/ apl202/ apl204/ apl206/ visaprom.com/ |
Vladimir 30-Oct-2008 [752] | never mind ..... :) you are good guys :) |
Graham 30-Oct-2008 [753x2] | yep, works for me too .... |
must be your router | |
Vladimir 30-Oct-2008 [755] | so where to look for error? |
Pekr 30-Oct-2008 [756] | There seems to be problem with cmd port. But that runs on port 21, whereas data usually runs on 20. Have you tried with system/schemes/ftp/passive: true ? |
Graham 30-Oct-2008 [757x4] | tried that |
it's not a server problem ... | |
as it works for us | |
have you tried puting your PC into the DMZ ? | |
Pekr 30-Oct-2008 [761] | Dunno how FTP works, but if not in passive mode, then ftp server tries to open data port on your side, but that might not be true. Definitely some issue on the router ... |
older newer | first last |