World: r3wp
[!REBOL3-OLD1]
older newer | first last |
Sunanda 15-Sep-2009 [17572] | There is already a language with a very similar name: Zeno http://home.att.net/~srschmitt/zeno.html |
Oldes 15-Sep-2009 [17573] | There is also more than 10000000 "Zen language" pages |
Henrik 15-Sep-2009 [17574] | I don't think renaming REBOL itself is a good idea. However not mentioning the name in products powered by REBOL, might be a good idea. |
Geomol 15-Sep-2009 [17575] | If a new version of REBOL is very different from what we know as REBOL today, then it might be ok with a name-change. If it's just a new version in a line of versions of REBOL coming from Carl, then I think, it would be more confusing to rename it. And what's the point of a rename? The name is not the reason, the language is not more widespread. List of programming languages: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_programming_languages |
Maxim 15-Sep-2009 [17576x2] | somehow, I've always found that rebol sounded boyish. |
and IMHO zen is a very appropriate name for the language itself. but I agree that in web searches it would be quite hard to find stuff... which is extremely easy today with REBOL. | |
BrianH 15-Sep-2009 [17578x2] | That's why the typo-names are popular (like Google). |
Google was an unintentional typo of googol. | |
Maxim 15-Sep-2009 [17580x2] | zen script is already used by a vertical market company in dtp to web services. |
zen script would be a very cool name IMHO :-D | |
Geomol 15-Sep-2009 [17582x2] | How does Erlang sound to you? Boyish? Business? What? |
How does IDL sound? | |
Maxim 15-Sep-2009 [17584] | REBOL sounds boyish because its a bad typo of Rebel. |
Henrik 15-Sep-2009 [17585] | I think changing the name is going to severely add confusion to what it is that Carl is trying to sell people/developers. For one, it's not likely to help getting old REBOLers back in the fold. We would have to waste a large amount of time explaining the relationship between REBOL and <whatever name>. Probably much more than we realize. REBOL 2 and REBOL 3 are understandable immediately in the same sense that PHP4 and PHP5 are. What would happen if Microsoft renamed DirectX or if Javascript changed to a new name? Confusion. Nothing more. |
BrianH 15-Sep-2009 [17586] | Erlang sounds technical and boring, but is OK. IDL sounds like the government made it. |
Maxim 15-Sep-2009 [17587] | it really gives out the impression that you are out to "teach people a lesson" and very few people in an ego filled space like programming responds well to that. |
BrianH 15-Sep-2009 [17588] | The word Rebel is boyish - the typo just sounds like it came from a tech company (everyone does it). |
Geomol 15-Sep-2009 [17589] | Forth is so named because in 1968 "[t]he file holding the interpreter was labeled FOURTH, for 4th (next) generation software Ñ but the IBM 1130 operating system restricted file names to 5 characters." :-) |
Maxim 15-Sep-2009 [17590] | try telling you sysadmin that you know better than him.... and watch your account space be reduce by 50%.... if he had a bad day make that 1byte more than its current size ;-) |
BrianH 15-Sep-2009 [17591] | Programming is a boyish field - Peter Pan style, keeping your creativity and edge by never getting old. |
Maxim 15-Sep-2009 [17592x2] | I'd prefer it being REALLY blunt... then its funny.... maybe we could rename REBOL to "Fanboy" ;-D |
pekr would be our king ;-) | |
Henrik 15-Sep-2009 [17594x2] | The perceived problem with the name REBOL, is that it's very over exposed. Count the number of times you see REBOL, REBOL, REBOL, REBOL in capitals from the time you download R2 to the time you are fiddling around in the Viewtop. Too much exposure of the name. But it's because Carl is proud of the name. Tone it down for R3 and we'll be fine. Some people think REBOL is a derivative of ALGOL or COBOL, but that's a separate issue. |
Javascript has the same problem with Java. | |
Geomol 15-Sep-2009 [17596] | If Carl wanna change it, it would be interesting to know, what motive he has for changing it. |
Maxim 15-Sep-2009 [17597x2] | Carl never liked the name... it was imposed to him by the marketing dept when he was still a startup. IIRC |
in the days when RT was actually a company with 30 employees | |
Henrik 15-Sep-2009 [17599] | Really? I don't get that impression in conversations with him. (We've talked alot about being rebellious and using camouflage colors) |
BrianH 15-Sep-2009 [17600] | Heard a great line, don't remember from where: "Java has as much to do with JavaScript as Ham has to do with Hamster" |
Henrik 15-Sep-2009 [17601] | :-) |
BrianH 15-Sep-2009 [17602] | (paraphrased) |
Maxim 15-Sep-2009 [17603] | :-D |
Geomol 15-Sep-2009 [17604x3] | It's kinda strange, they got along with calling it JavaScript. I would think, Sun would be able to stop it somehow. |
Should we try make DirectXScript? ;-) | |
Of course it should have nothing to do with DirectX, but be the link between iPhone apps and Amiga ... or something. | |
Maxim 15-Sep-2009 [17607] | call it DirectScript :-) |
BrianH 15-Sep-2009 [17608] | Can ActiveScripting languages call DirectX? I would think so... |
Maxim 15-Sep-2009 [17609] | sanskript in relation to zen ? :-) |
Geomol 15-Sep-2009 [17610x2] | :-) |
Dharma | |
amacleod 15-Sep-2009 [17612] | Call it R as in R3...we'll always know what it means.... It worked for C and there was also an E script language on the Amiga |
Maxim 15-Sep-2009 [17613] | it already exists... its a statistical language |
Henrik 15-Sep-2009 [17614] | ARR, then. Pirate language. |
Maxim 15-Sep-2009 [17615] | hahaha that would really sit in well with MIS... hahaha "looks guys... we've got a process called pirate.exe"... think its a hacker? response... No ... he'd be too stupid to use a name like that! ;-) |
Sunanda 15-Sep-2009 [17616] | Then name it after a real (and/or legendary) pirate.....drumroll.....Alvilda http://towim.denmasters.com/rp/alvilda/pirate.htm (Contorted acronym available later) |
Pekr 15-Sep-2009 [17617] | Maxim - where do you come up with such info that Carl is open to renaming REBOL? I can't see anything like that floating around ... the REBOL rename is total nonsense and anyone claiming otherwise should take some marketing pills ... |
Maxim 15-Sep-2009 [17618x2] | REBOL-SIG altme group... mid-august |
doh... I meant REBOL-SIG Qtask project | |
Pekr 15-Sep-2009 [17620x2] | REBOL being written in capital is another nonsense spread by many ... |
If it is true, I might be out from this community. This is really totally non-professional aproach. REBOL's problems lay completly elsewhere, not in the name itself. If Carl can't see it, noone can help the situation ... | |
older newer | first last |