World: r4wp
[#Red] Red language group
older newer | first last |
Arnold 23-Nov-2012 [4334] | (Seconded. If there is a link with Red, the link to Red is to prevent the same mistakes made again) |
Kaj 23-Nov-2012 [4335x2] | Brian, Maxim, the point of ALIAS is that it works with refinements. : : value assignments can't do that |
The Chinese are going to take over the world, and they may well consider it an educational mistake to translate their Chinese R3 fork to English. To prevent having to learn Chinese, you could translate it back with ALIAS | |
Arnold 23-Nov-2012 [4337] | The Chinese will have to take their world dominance from you first ;) |
Kaj 23-Nov-2012 [4338] | They've already taken all my cousins in marriage... |
Ladislav 23-Nov-2012 [4339] | Well, at least in tennis, currently the world dominance is here in Cz ;-) |
BrianH 23-Nov-2012 [4340] | Kaj, you can translate refinements using wrapper functions, and it's a better approach when you need to combine code from several nationalized sources. If you accept the idea of nationalized code, then you have to accept multi-nationalized code. This kind of thing is why I made sure R3 supported private modules. |
Kaj 23-Nov-2012 [4341x2] | That's an awful lot of wrapper functions, can't be done by a pure translator, and degrades performance |
You'd still have to read Chinese to figure out what the code does | |
BrianH 23-Nov-2012 [4343] | Right. As opposed to ALIAS, which can bring your system to a crashing halt, if you're lucky; if you're not lucky it will fail silently and stay a security hole. |
Kaj 23-Nov-2012 [4344x2] | With paren!, Fibonacci is now: |
parameter: 40 fibonacci: func [n [integer!]] [ either n < 2 [n] [(fibonacci n - 1) + fibonacci n - 2] ] prin "Fibonacci " prin parameter prin ": " print fibonacci parameter | |
BrianH 23-Nov-2012 [4346] | To illustrate my point in a dumb way: alias 'true "false" |
Kaj 23-Nov-2012 [4347x4] | Yes, that's dumb enough that anyone would quickly figure out not to do that |
Anyway, I increased the parameters of both Fibonacci and Mandelbrot to have a better benchmarking range for fast languages, such as Red/System | |
With this parameter and a more exact comparison, Red/System is 70 times faster than Red | |
Red is 2.2 times faster than R3 | |
BrianH 23-Nov-2012 [4351] | Kaj, you are assuming that people don't want to create deliberate bugs. If any REBOL-like language with an interpreter of JIT becomes popular, we are going to have to assume that some developers will be malicious. Remember SQL-injection attacks. Don't add a feature that is only better than another way of doing that feature in that it is so trivially easy to use as an attack vector that anyone could use it with the stupidest code imaginable. |
Kaj 23-Nov-2012 [4352] | Programming is a security hole. If you want to allow people to do safe programming, you have to make it safe by disallowing many things. That would obviously include ALIAS |
BrianH 23-Nov-2012 [4353] | Also, REBOL-like languages are easy to generate from a dialect. A translator could write data files in a dialect, which could be used to generate the wrapper functions and assignment statements. And a half-way decent optimizer could get rid of the wrappers using the same methods that would allow it to statically resolve refinements. There's no reason to support an astoundly worse method. |
Kaj 23-Nov-2012 [4354] | I will happily allow people to use ALIAS on my Try REBOL server, just like I'm allowing most other REBOL features, because the server operating system is the party that establishes safe boundaries |
BrianH 23-Nov-2012 [4355] | astoundly -> astoundingly Bad typing day. |
Kaj 23-Nov-2012 [4356x4] | You are welcome to try our server to see if you can break it with ALIAS |
On my machine, REBOL catches up enormously when it can do many iterations in a very small loop. Apparently, a very small function will eventually fit in the CPU cache, so the VM gets less of a cache hit compared to compiled languages | |
With increased iterations, the effect is big in Fibonacci, but dramatic in Mandelbrot | |
Of course, most programs do not afford that advantage | |
BrianH 23-Nov-2012 [4360] | I remember there being a spreadsheet expression evaluator that made it a point to have a small enough number of operations in its bytecode that it could fit two operations per byte. That means that with cache issues taken into account, its code was drastically faster than fully compiled code. The interpreter fit entirely in the instruction cache of a 486, and the bytecode was much smaller than regular native instructions, so the bytecode could be pushed into the CPU faster. This kind of a thing is even more of an issue now, with CPUs that are many times more faster than the memory busses, and even bigger caches. |
Kaj 23-Nov-2012 [4361] | On Mandelbrot with 50'000 iterations instead of the standard 1000, Red/System is 80 times faster than R3 |
BrianH 23-Nov-2012 [4362x2] | R3 is obviously not designed with that kind of interpreter though, and isn't even bytecode compiled. That is more a trick for rebcode :) |
GPU shader languages often use that trick though. | |
Kaj 24-Nov-2012 [4364x2] | If anyone wants to help Red and thinks he can't start programming yet, please give it a presence here under Tested on RPi: |
http://elinux.org/RPi_Programming | |
Arnold 24-Nov-2012 [4366] | I have to wait to start programming my Raspberry Pi until I actually get it from Sinterklaas. After that I can try to test Red on it. I watched your presentation on programming in Red on the Raspberry Pi. No Syllable yet? WHat Linux did you use on the Rasp again Kaj? |
Kaj 24-Nov-2012 [4367x5] | Ah, so you volunteer for editing the wiki :-) |
I said it in the video: Raspian, Arch Linux, and my preferred Bodhi Linux (based on Raspian) | |
Raspbian, that is | |
RISC OS runs best, though, but no Red | |
Syllable would have to be ported to ARM, which is a lot of work | |
Arnold 25-Nov-2012 [4372] | Possible to port Red to RISC OS too? Or a lot of work too %Y\ ? I could contribute to the wiki (which one are we talking about here?) Now I have my 10x10 checkers game in Version 1.0.0 released I have some time to spend on the script Doc asked for. Can the specifications be reposted please? |
PeterWood 25-Nov-2012 [4373] | I have just uploaded a basic script to generate Red/System API docs to Github. It could do with a lot of polishing, perhaps you could take a look? |
Jerry 25-Nov-2012 [4374] | Red/System API Docs ... Just what I need, Thanks, Peter. :-) |
Marco 25-Nov-2012 [4375] | I would like to report a bug in red-system. I would prefer not to register myself anywhere. Which is the simplest way ? |
Kaj 25-Nov-2012 [4376] | Arnold, I'm talking about the RPi wiki I linked above |
Arnold 25-Nov-2012 [4377] | Added to the favorites! |
DocKimbel 25-Nov-2012 [4378] | Marco, you can report it here, and someone will then re-post it in the bugtracker on github. |
Marco 25-Nov-2012 [4379] | red-system question: How can I create a simple array of constants? |
Kaj 25-Nov-2012 [4380x4] | That's a bit tricky. There's no explicit support for specifying that |
You can write such a list in the arguments of a function, so you can make a constructor function that takes the constants and delivers the array | |
Actually, when you use a typed constructor function, you already get access to the arguments array, but it's an array of stuct!s of type typed-value! | |
If you can use the array in that form, you can use that trick, but you have to stay within the function because the array is on the stack | |
older newer | first last |